Geoffrey are slain inside a biking accident from inside the 1186 and you may Constance partnered (2) Ranulph de Blundeville, 4 th Earl from Chester, towards step 3 rd March 1188, during the a marriage set-up because of the Queen Henry 11. This marriage deteriorated and you may Ranulph imprisoned Constance in 1196. Rebellions was in fact sparked round the Brittany on her behalf and you can Ranulph put-out their own from inside the 1198. Back to Brittany, Constance got their particular matrimony annulled and later into the 1198, she grabbed Man de Tours while the their own ‘second’ partner.
Constance died aged forty, (maybe regarding leprosy, perhaps following childbirth to twin girls) towards 5 th Sep 1201 from the Nantes
The theory that Constance got an affair having John following loss of Geoffrey and you can before John’s marriage so you can Isabella away from Gloucester in the 1189, and therefore she are mother so you can Joanna is really controversial and provides provoked much discussion inside genealogical sectors.
From the merely that have sex having John, aside from hit him a child, Constance would have built a primary-education matchmaking regarding attraction with John’s sisters –– together with John’s sister Geoffrey
You to definitely remark out of a great genealogist says you to definitely ‘the newest log ‘The Plantagenet Connection’ possess authored a keen ahnentafel of Age Plantagenet, wife of Henry V11, which provides Joanna’s mom’s label given that Constance (maybe misnamed Clemence?), Duchess regarding Brittany. Here is the Constance who was simply John’s sister-in-laws! Due to the well-known animosity ranging from John and you may Constance along with her very own tries to force their particular young buck Arthur’s interests as far as the latest throne away from England try concerned (therefore all know how disastrously you to definitely turned out!), I truly discover the recommended matchmaking a small tough to consume. The Constance you to history depicts will not struck me personally just like the for the just who John can potentially coerce for the bed.’
‘ A concept who would select Joanna’s mommy just like the Constance does not account fully for a very vital point in canon rules. Who would mean that specific shade of your amount need to surely attended as a result of united states, if it on it the request they, this new deliberations, or the actual dispensation alone. As far as i in the morning aware, nothing of one’s type is available.’
My personal opinion for what it is worth, is that had Constance become the caretaker regarding Joanna she would definitely enjoys produced her upwards inside her domestic and her title would be as well also known as Constance’s other college students from the Geoffrey (Eleanor, Reasonable Maid away from Brittany, Matilda/Maud away from Brittany and you may Arthur).
Agatha was born from the 1168 into the Chartley Castle, Staffordshire. It’s well known you to she is actually a domme of John and many family unit members trees render their, no matter if single, due to the fact mother out of Joanna. Very genealogists although not are of the opinion that it is merely conjecture one to she’s Joanna’s mother due to the fact zero evidence otherwise info can be found showing this.
Although this wasn’t good consanguineous relationships but among affinity, people very first-studies relationship would have made relationships ranging from Constance and you can any of John’s brothers hopeless without a dispensation –– and therefore because of the party’s score would have must come from brand new pope themselves
You to source frequently considering is actually Sir William Dugdale, on the Baronage off England (1675-6). According to him his origin are Dr David Howell’s ‘Reputation for Wales’ (1584). Powell’s tasks are an enlarged edition from H Lloyd’s translation regarding ‘New Historie out-of Cambria’ by the 12 th century Saint Caradoc regarding Llancarfan. A different sort of source, ‘Magna Carta Barons’ because of the Charles Browning, copyright laws 1969 also brands Agatha de Ferrers, daughter of Robert de Ferrers, next Earl from derby, as the Joanna’s mother.
In the event she can not be entirely disregarded since the an applicant to have mom out of Joanna, undoubtedly there would be certain shadow off their unique inside the good chronicle or other historic resource, when the she had in reality started the mother of one’s partner away from the newest Prince regarding North Wales.